Best Eggnog Latte Syrups for Every Home and Budget

True eggnog syrups are a small seasonal category, so we looked at both dedicated eggnog syrups and the classic building blocks baristas use. Based on ratings, ingredients and versatility, these three are among the best eggnog latte syrups you can buy for home lattes.

Best Overall Coffee Pick: Amoretti Premium Eggnog Syrup

Amoretti is a long established maker of syrups for cafes, and its eggnog syrup is one of the few dedicated eggnog options with strong early ratings. Early buyers give it a perfect score, though it has only a handful of reviews so far.

• Real eggnog flavor: made specifically for eggnog style coffees, cocktails and other drinks.
• Big bottle: 750 ml with about 94 servings and a pump included.
• Clean label: listed as gluten free, GMO free and preservative free.

Because it has few reviews, it is a newer pick than the classic syrups below. For anyone who wants true eggnog flavor in one pump, it is our top pick at around $32.

Check Price on Amazon

Best Value Brew: Torani French Vanilla Syrup 4 Pack

French vanilla is the backbone of most homemade eggnog lattes. Add a pinch of nutmeg and cinnamon and you are most of the way there. This Torani four pack holds a 4.8 star average from about 4,700 ratings.

• Creamy base: French vanilla adds the custard like sweetness eggnog is known for.
• Four bottles: four 25.4 ounce bottles, enough for months of lattes.
• Year round use: works in coffee, hot chocolate and baking long after the holidays.

You will need to add spices yourself to get a true eggnog taste, and four bottles take up space. For frequent latte makers, it is a great value at around $26.

Check Price on Amazon

Best for Coffee Snobs: Deiman Eggnog Flavoring

Home baristas who like to control sweetness can use a concentrated flavoring instead of a sugary syrup. Deiman eggnog flavoring holds a 4.8 star average from its buyers.

• Concentrated: a little goes a long way in lattes, desserts and homemade syrups.
• Large size: a 33.8 fluid ounce bottle for serious use.
• Sweeten your way: add your preferred sweetener or none at all.

It is an artificial flavoring and needs careful measuring, so it suits people comfortable experimenting. For coffee snobs who want flavor without extra sugar, it is a useful pick at around $49.

Check Price on Amazon

Choosing eggnog latte syrups comes down to flavor, sweetness and how often you make lattes. Here is what to compare.

Flavor Profile and Sweetness

Good eggnog flavor tastes like vanilla custard with warm nutmeg and a touch of cinnamon. Some syrups lean sweet and candy like, while others taste more like real eggnog. Reviews often mention whether a syrup tastes natural or artificial.

Consider how the drink will be served, too. A sweeter syrup suits lattes made with plenty of milk, while a lighter touch works better in a small cortado or an iced coffee where the flavor is more noticeable.

Freshness and Packaging

Most syrups keep for months, but flavor fades after opening. Bottles with a pump help with portion control and keep the syrup cleaner. Check the best by date on seasonal syrups, which may sit in storage between holidays.

Drink and Brewer Fit

Syrups work with espresso, drip coffee, cold brew and even hot chocolate. If you do not have an espresso machine, strong brewed coffee or a moka pot makes a good latte base.

Ingredients and Dietary Needs

Check whether a syrup uses cane sugar, artificial sweeteners or none at all. Look for gluten free or preservative free labels if they matter to you, and note that most eggnog syrups contain no actual egg or dairy, though you should always read the label.

Quantity and Value

Compare cost per serving. A 750 ml bottle typically makes dozens of drinks, while multi packs lower the price per bottle. Small sample sizes are good for trying a flavor first.

Gift Presentation

A bottle of eggnog syrup with a festive mug, a jar of nutmeg and a milk frother makes a charming gift. Add a recipe card for an easy eggnog latte.

Eggnog flavor comes in a few forms. Here is how they compare.

Ready made eggnog syrups

The simplest option: one pump gives you eggnog flavor and sweetness.

Vanilla and spice syrups

French vanilla, cinnamon and gingerbread syrups combine into a homemade eggnog style latte.

Samplers and sets

Syrup variety packs let you try several holiday flavors at once.

Accessories

Milk frothers, ground nutmeg and flavored toppings finish the drink.

The product table also includes Torani cinnamon and gingerbread syrups, DaVinci white chocolate syrup, Crazy Cups caramel eggnog ground coffee, eggnog hot chocolate packets, an eggnog flavored powdered sugar for topping and a handheld milk frother.

A great eggnog latte is simple once you know the ratios.

Dialing In the Brew

Start with a double shot of espresso or half a cup of strong coffee, add one to two pumps of syrup and top with about eight ounces of steamed milk. Adjust the syrup to taste, since eggnog flavor can quickly become too sweet.

Holiday Drink Ideas

For a homemade version, mix one pump of French vanilla with a pinch of nutmeg and cinnamon. Top with whipped cream and a dusting of nutmeg, or serve it iced over cold milk. Eggnog syrup also works in hot chocolate for kids.

You can even make a simple homemade eggnog syrup. Simmer one cup of sugar with one cup of water until dissolved, then stir in a teaspoon of vanilla, a quarter teaspoon of nutmeg and a pinch of cinnamon. Cool it, strain it into a clean bottle and keep it in the fridge for up to two weeks.

Storing for Freshness

Store syrups in a cool, dark cupboard and keep the pump clean. Rinse the pump occasionally with warm water to prevent sticky buildup.

Yes. A bottle of syrup is an affordable, festive gift for coffee lovers, coworkers, teachers and hosts. It lets the recipient enjoy cafe style drinks at home all season.

Shoppers looking for eggnog latte syrups for Christmas can bundle a bottle with a milk frother and a holiday mug. For more cozy ideas, see our guide to the best hot chocolate gift sets and our roundup of the best coffee syrups gift sets. Check Amazon's holiday shipping page for this year's cutoff dates.

The most common mistake is using too much syrup, which hides the coffee and makes the drink cloying. Start with one pump and add more if needed.

Another mistake is skipping the spice. A sprinkle of fresh nutmeg makes even a simple vanilla latte taste like eggnog. Finally, check ingredients for anyone with dietary restrictions, and buy seasonal syrups early since they can sell out before December.

Quick answers about top rated eggnog latte syrups.

How long do eggnog latte syrups stay fresh?

Most unopened syrups last many months. Once opened, use them within the time frame on the label for the best flavor.

Are eggnog latte syrups a good gift for coffee or tea lovers?

They are a great gift for coffee lovers and also work in chai lattes, so tea drinkers can enjoy them too.

What is the best way to make an eggnog latte?

Combine espresso or strong coffee with one to two pumps of syrup, add steamed milk and top with nutmeg.

Do eggnog latte syrups contain caffeine?

No. The syrups are caffeine free; the caffeine comes from the coffee or espresso you add.

When should you buy eggnog latte syrups for Christmas?

Buy in November, since seasonal syrups appear in the fall and can sell out before December.

The best eggnog latte syrups bring a cafe favorite into your kitchen. Amoretti eggnog syrup is our top pick for true eggnog flavor, the Torani French Vanilla four pack is the best value base for homemade versions and Deiman flavoring suits coffee snobs who control their own sweetness.

Start with one pump, add a dash of nutmeg and check the product table above for current prices on Amazon.